Striking up the intermediate band

June 21, 2007 - Exclusive By Dallas Kachan, Cleantech Group

In the world of solar photovolatics, today's high performance multijunction cell is the undisputed rock star. And where there are rock stars, wannabes lurk in the wings.

The leading advocate of a promising new high performance solar cell technology, Dr. Antonio Luque of the Polytechnic University of Madrid, today introduced his "intermediate band" cell design to an audience of largely polo-shirted researchers in a lecture at the fabled Palo Alto Research Center (PARC), formerly Xerox PARC, in Palo Alto, California. [ed.: as a matter of fact, we only counted one suit in the room.]

While still largely theoretical, Luque's intermediate band design could promise efficiencies even higher than today's highest performing multijunction cells.

Multijunction cells are made of layers of materials far more expensive than the silicon conventional cells are made of, but they deliver efficiencies about double those of everyday solar panels.

As such, they're only economically viable in military applications, where cost is not an issue, and high concentration applications in which their expense can be justified by converting large volumes of sunlight.

Late last year, Boeing's Spectrolab introduced a 40.7% efficient cell (see Spectrolab solar cell breaks 40% efficiency barrier), but that's close to the theoretical limit of multijunction cells as architected today, according to Luque.

Multijunction cells are complex; the three layers of cells used to harvest electricity from different bands of the spectrum are actually made up of a total of twenty layers of material.

To make the jump from 40 percent efficiency to a potential upper limit of 45 percent projected in 2009, scientists' roadmaps call for potentially adding a fourth cell, complicating things further.

By contrast, Luque's design calls for essentially three layers of materials: a conventional "n+ emitter" layer, a "intermediate band material" and a "p+ emitter layer." When exposed to high amounts of concentrated sunlight (the design is inefficient unless used with multi-sun concentration), the cell harvests photons from across the spectrum with only a minimal compromise in today's tradeoff between current and voltage.

"Most semiconductor devices split into two Fermi levels. We are using three Fermi levels, including one for the intermediate, and this seperation is the secret to how we can get at the same time high voltage and high power."

Luque thinks he can get to 63.2 percent theoretical efficiency in his design, using only three layers.

The chief hurdle, however, is that material for one of those layers, the critical intermediate band middle, hasn't been fully thought out yet. Luque's prototypes to date have used quantum dot material, and he has been looking at gallium arsenide, indium arsenide and other more exotic compounds.

Luque acknowledged he and his researchers had some false starts and got results opposite to what they originally intended. They were initially unsure how to measure whether their design was even working, but are now confident in it.

"We illuminated with lights of different frequencies, and then testing their response to the different frequencies, and then chopped at different frequencies. Then we were able to prove clearly that we were having the process we were looking for."

While promising revolutionary levels of performance, Luque cautioned the crowd that the design will only be applicable in highly concentrated sunlight applications. But that's the direction utility-grade solar power is headed, he affirmed.

"My vision is that in the future, most solar electricity will be produced with systems of very, very high efficiency. We'll be forced to used concentrators, because this will be the only way of making these sophisticated and expensive concepts economical. Concentration is the secret to doing it cheaper."

Luque is so passionate about concentration as the future of solar that he convinced the Spanish government to create and fund ISFOC, the Institute of Concentration Photovoltaic Systems. The institute recently issued a call for tenders to concentrating photovoltaic systems vendors, with a view to buying test systems to help them accelerate their paths to commercialization.

Contracts have been awarded to SolFocus of the U.S., Isofotón of Spain and Concentrix of Germany.

Luque, who himself proudly sported a SolFocus polo shirt today, has been Full Professor of electronic technology at the Polytechnic University of Madrid since 1970, and has led the Instituto de Energía Solar since founding it in 1979. He invented the bifacial solar cell in 1976, brought to market by Isofotón, a company he created in 1982, today present in more than 50 countries.

Coverage brought to you by

Cleantech developments making news in the past 24 hours

Comments

That's a lotta virtual ink...

...spent on something that is barely working in the labs yet. Sure it's cool, but will this ever be real?

Conversion efficiency including thermal could be even higher

Hello --

Truly Dr. Luque's is a far-out and revolutionary proposal! I did some thinking about the possible implications. Although I haven't worked in this field, I think that heliostats for solar power towers could be very cheap (my model is reflective Mylar kites aimed by $1 distributed microcontrollers). So high-efficiency concentrated-solar power generation could also be very cost-effective, despite needing relatively sophisticated and expensive technology at the towers.

A further gain in efficiency may be possible. The long infrared radiation no solar cell utilizes could be separated out with wavelength-selective mirrors (WSM) (note that ThermoPhotoVoltaic or TPV systems require these to work at all.) The infrared could be collected to power Stirling or steam engines as in standard solar thermal systems. What would the theoretical limit of efficiency be for such a system? If the other 37% of total sunlight could be separated and concentrated efficiently, perhaps achieving a Carnot efficiency of 33%, then the theoretical conversion efficiency would be a shocking 63+12=75% of total solar irradiance.

Of course, there will be many, many difficulties achieving anything like it, but that's an impressive goal. In my 2 decades in the semiconductor industry, I saw seemingly impossible progress, limited only by basic physics. It seems to me that some equivalent of Moore's Law in the relatively virgin research field of solar energy (no offense!) could bring us very close to these physical limits. Today's global energy and climate crises provide motivation for the kind of sustained, massive R&D efforts that could achieve that.

Highly efficient and cost-effective solar plants, widely implemented in desert regions where there are few alternative uses for the land, could play a significant role in world energy economics in the coming decades. Here's hoping!

I've looked into the issue

I've looked into the issue of ultra high energy efficiency conversion solar before, and found an interesting design called the multi tower solar array (MTSA). It's a fresnel multi tower design that captures about 90 percent of the available beam, and focuses that onto a reveiver. The receiver is divided into two parts, one thermal, one PV wavelengths. The beam is split by a beam splitting coating. PV on the top, a heat engine on the bottom.

Another promising option is infrared nano-antenna technology. Up to 80 percent conversion efficiency could be achieved. Because the design converts infrared - heat - it could use cheap thermal storage to produce a longer portion of the day.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Become a cleantech industry insider - sign up for our free newsletter